Table of Contents

Complexities of OpenXML SDK

The OpenXML SDK (Software Development Kit) is a powerful tool for working with Microsoft Office files, particularly for manipulating Word documents in a programmatic way. It allows developers to create, modify, and analyze documents in the Open XML format used by Microsoft Word. While the SDK offers a wide range of capabilities, it comes with certain complexities that developers must be aware of to ensure their documents are correctly structured and behave as expected. In this article, we will explore some of the intricacies and challenges associated with using the OpenXML SDK, and how to overcome them.

Sequence Matters

The OpenXML SDK is a collection of various XML elements that can be used to create Word documents. One of the most significant complexities is that the SDK does not validate the structure. It allows users to append elements in any sequence they choose. However, this flexibility can lead to issues. For example, appending a child to the Body via OpenXML SDK may place it at the end after the section (represented as SectionProperties in OpenXML SDK), potentialy resulting in a corrupted document.

Example: Wrong Element Append

// Wrong Append to Body
Paragraph paragraph = new Paragraph();
ParagraphProperties paragraphProperties = new ParagraphProperties();
paragraph.Append(paragraphProperties);

Body body = mainDocumentPart.Document.Body;
body.AppendChild(paragraph);

Example: Correct Element Append

// Correct Append to Body
Paragraph paragraph = new Paragraph();
ParagraphProperties paragraphProperties = new ParagraphProperties();
paragraph.Append(paragraphProperties);

Body body = mainDocumentPart.Document.Body;
var sectionPropertiesList = body.Elements<WP.SectionProperties>().ToList();
if (sectionPropertiesList.Any())
{
   var lastSectionProperties = sectionPropertiesList.Last();
   body.InsertBefore(paragraph, lastSectionProperties);
}                       

FontFamily Placement

In OpenXML, the sequence in which you define FontFamily is crucial. Placing FontFamily in RunProperties before any other XML element is vital. If FontFamily is appended after other font attributes, Microsoft Word might overlook the specified FontFamily and default to its standard font (usually Calibri). To prevent this, ensure 'FontFamily' defined in RunFonts is added to RunProperties before any other font-related XML elements within RunProperties.

Example: Wrong FontFamily Placement

// Wrong FontFamily Placement
var wpRunWrong = new WP.Run();
var runPropertiesWrong = new WP.RunProperties();
var colorWrong = new WP.Color { Val = "#0000FF" };
runPropertiesWrong.Append(colorWrong);
var runFontWrong = new WP.RunFonts { Ascii = "Arial" };
runPropertiesWrong.Append(runFontWrong);
// Add other font properties as needed

Example: Correct FontFamily Placement

// Correct FontFamily Placement
var wpRunCorrect = new WP.Run();
var runPropertiesCorrect = new WP.RunProperties();
var runFontCorrect = new WP.RunFonts { Ascii = "Arial" };
runPropertiesCorrect.Append(runFontCorrect);
var colorCorrect = new WP.Color { Val = "#0000FF" };
runPropertiesCorrect.Append(colorCorrect);
// Add other font properties as needed

TableProperties Placement

The positioning of table properties is crucial for proper document interpretation in Word. If you append TableProperties after adding the table, row properties, or cell properties, Microsoft Word might overlook these XML elements. To avoid this issue, it is essential to define TableProperties before other related elements, such as rows and cells.

Example: Wrong TableProperties Placement

// Wrong Table Properties Placement
Table tableWrong = new Table();
TableProperties tablePropertiesWrong = new TableProperties();
TableRow tableRowWrong = new TableRow();
TableRowProperties tableRowPropertiesWrong = new TableRowProperties();
TableCell tableCellWrong = new TableCell();
TableCellProperties tableCellPropertiesWrong = new TableCellProperties();

tableCellWrong.Append(tableCellPropertiesWrong);
tableRowWrong.Append(tableRowPropertiesWrong);
tableRowWrong.Append(tableCellWrong);
tableWrong.Append(tableRowWrong);
tableWrong.Append(tablePropertiesWrong);

Example: Correct TableProperties Placement

// Correct Table Properties Placement
Table tableCorrect = new Table();
TableProperties tablePropertiesCorrect = new TableProperties();
TableRow tableRowCorrect = new TableRow();
TableRowProperties tableRowPropertiesCorrect = new TableRowProperties();
TableCell tableCellCorrect = new TableCell();
TableCellProperties tableCellPropertiesCorrect = new TableCellProperties();

tableCellCorrect.Append(tableCellPropertiesCorrect);
tableRowCorrect.Append(tableRowPropertiesCorrect);
tableRowCorrect.Append(tableCellCorrect);
tableCorrect.Append(tablePropertiesCorrect);
tableCorrect.Append(tableRowCorrect);

Overcoming the Challenges

To work effectively with the OpenXML SDK, developers need to understand the valid sequences that Microsoft Word can recognize and understand. Failing to follow these sequences can result in unpredictable document behavior. In some cases, Word may attempt to correct the document based on its default behavior, but in the worst cases, the document may become corrupted.

One approach to mitigating these complexities is to use a wrapper or library that enforces the correct document structure. Tools like FileFormat.Words provide a higher-level API that simplifies the process of working with OpenXML and ensures that documents adhere to the expected structure.

Conclusion

In summary, the OpenXML SDK is a valuable resource for working with Word documents, especially for complex tasks. It can load intricate Word documents correctly. However, when creating new documents or updating existing ones, developers must be mindful of the valid append sequences to achieve the desired results. Using FileFormat.Words or understanding Word's expectations for document structure can help streamline the development process and avoid potential pitfalls. With the right knowledge and tools, the OpenXML SDK can be a powerful ally in creating and manipulating Word documents programmatically.